Just pronounce is as you like - language changes all the time anyway

I've encountered both pronunciations (certainly the -may one in music lyrics, and the pun of
this show's title only works with the -met version).
Well, let's collect the relevant information:
It seems to be first found in Latin texts of the 11th century, and in 12th and 13th century Occitan poems:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baphomet#HistoryIf it's Latin, then usually every letter is pronounced, so that would be -met.
If it's Occitan, similar seems to apply:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Occitan#PhonologyWhen the word was used in the course of the trials against the templars, that was in the early 14th century France, so the relevant languages would be (early) Middle French, and medieval clerical Latin.
If it's Middle French - huh, seems like around 1500 there was a sound change by which final consonants were lost if the next word in a sentence started with a consonant. So that would be either -met or -meh, depending on the following word. But that's quite a bit late, so I would assume around 1300, it was still pronounced -met. No guarantees, though, just based on
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phonological_history_of_French#To_Late_Old_French,_c._1250%E2%80%931300Considering that Baphomet was made famous in modern times by Éliphas Lévi, a modern French native, we'd likely have to ask someone who speaks French (I don't) how to exactly pronounce it. But based on this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_orthography it seems to be -meh.
Take your pick, you now have an additional option
